So, our lease isn't up until March 31st. That doesn't stop me from searching Craigslist every day and keeping tabs on what's available in the area we've been looking in (Hillcrest, Banker's Hill, Mission Hills, North Park, University Heights, etc) and I found the cutest place.
It's a house, and it's small. It's about 1000 square feet, 2 bedroom 1 1/2 baths. One of the bedrooms is super tiny, and probably best suited to an office long term. The other bedroom is nice and big. The whole place is newly upgraded, with new appliances, washer/dryer, jacuzzi bathtub, nice hardwood floors, and a super cute kitchen. It has a big backyard with a doggie door so Bella (and our future French Bulldog, Beanbag) can run around freely. I think even though it's small, it will be super cute for us. The living spaces are nice sized, it's just the bathrooms that are really small. I think with some creative storage and shelving, we could maximize the space to make it fit us great.
It's not for sure yet - but we got approval from our landlord to get out of our lease 1 month early as long as he finds a replacement. I also have a rental application for this new place and it seems like they really want us to get it. I'm trying not to get my hopes up - but I am finding myself getting really excited about having a yard for Bella and being close to the dog park and Balboa Park and Hillcrest and everything. There is plenty of shed storage and parking too. Here are some pictures of the place.